The 10-Complement Rule: When Numbers Cross Column Boundaries
Master the soroban 10-complement rule for carrying and borrowing across columns. Comprehensive guide with friends of 10 pairs, step-by-step examples, combined techniques, and expert tips from an occupational therapist mom.
As a pediatric occupational therapist, I've spent 12 years helping children develop fine motor skills and cognitive abilities. When my oldest daughter struggled with carrying and borrowing in second grade, I discovered the soroban - and specifically, the 10-complement rule. What amazed me wasn't just that it worked, but HOW it worked: the physical manipulation of beads across columns made the abstract concept of place value tangible. Now all three of my kids use this technique, and I recommend it to many families in my practice.
What is the 10-Complement Rule?
The 10-complement rule is the soroban technique for handling calculations that cross column boundaries - what traditional math calls 'carrying' (in addition) or 'borrowing' (in subtraction). When a calculation would result in more than 9 in a column or require subtracting more than is available, you use 10-complement to shift value between columns.
The 10-complement is often called 'friends of 10' because it's based on number pairs that always add up to 10. There are nine pairs total, and mastering them is essential for multi-digit calculations.
The Nine 10-Complement Pairs
Unlike 5-complement which has only four pairs, 10-complement has nine pairs to learn. The good news is that they're symmetrical - once you learn half, you automatically know the other half:
| Pair A | Pair B | Sum | Memory Trick |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 9 | 10 | 1 and 9 - almost there! |
| 2 | 8 | 10 | 2 and 8 - great mates |
| 3 | 7 | 10 | 3 and 7 - heaven |
| 4 | 6 | 10 | 4 and 6 - perfect mix |
| 5 | 5 | 10 | 5 and 5 - twins! |
| 6 | 4 | 10 | (same as 4+6) |
| 7 | 3 | 10 | (same as 3+7) |
| 8 | 2 | 10 | (same as 2+8) |
| 9 | 1 | 10 | (same as 1+9) |
Why Children Need 10-Complement
From my occupational therapy perspective, the 10-complement addresses one of the biggest hurdles in elementary math: understanding place value and regrouping. When children physically move beads between columns, they're not just memorizing procedures - they're building genuine number sense.
- •Traditional carrying/borrowing is often taught as a memorized procedure without understanding
- •Children frequently make errors because they don't visualize what's happening
- •The soroban makes the 'exchange' of 10 ones for 1 ten visible and tangible
- •This physical experience builds lasting mathematical intuition
- •Children who learn 10-complement often outperform peers in mental math
10-Complement Addition (Carrying): The Core Concept
When adding two numbers would give you more than 9 in a column, you can't show that result on the soroban (each column maxes out at 9). Instead, you carry to the next column. The rule is: ADD 1 to the tens column, SUBTRACT the complement from the ones column.
Think of it as making change: if you have 8 and add 5, you get 13. You can't show 13 in one column, so you 'trade' 10 ones for 1 ten. The complement tells you what's left over.
Example 1: Calculating 8 + 5
- •Step 1: Set 8 on the ones column (heaven bead down + 3 earth beads up)
- •Step 2: Analyze - you want to add 5, but 8 + 5 = 13, which exceeds 9
- •Step 3: Find the complement - 5's complement is 5 (because 5 + 5 = 10)
- •Step 4: Execute - Add 1 to tens column, subtract 5 from ones column (8 - 5 = 3)
- •Step 5: Read result - 13 (1 in tens, 3 in ones)
Example 2: Calculating 7 + 6
- •Step 1: Set 7 on the ones column
- •Step 2: Analyze - 7 + 6 = 13, exceeds 9
- •Step 3: Find the complement - 6's complement is 4 (because 6 + 4 = 10)
- •Step 4: Execute - Add 1 to tens column, subtract 4 from ones column (7 - 4 = 3)
- •Step 5: Read result - 13
| Problem | Exceeds 9? | Complement | Action | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 9 + 4 | Yes (13) | 6 | Add 10, subtract 6 | 13 |
| 7 + 6 | Yes (13) | 4 | Add 10, subtract 4 | 13 |
| 8 + 7 | Yes (15) | 3 | Add 10, subtract 3 | 15 |
| 6 + 8 | Yes (14) | 2 | Add 10, subtract 2 | 14 |
| 9 + 9 | Yes (18) | 1 | Add 10, subtract 1 | 18 |
| 5 + 7 | Yes (12) | 3 | Add 10, subtract 3 | 12 |
| 8 + 8 | Yes (16) | 2 | Add 10, subtract 2 | 16 |
| 7 + 9 | Yes (16) | 1 | Add 10, subtract 1 | 16 |
10-Complement Subtraction (Borrowing): The Core Concept
When subtracting a number larger than what's in the ones column, you need to borrow from the tens column. The rule is: SUBTRACT 1 from the tens column, ADD the complement to the ones column.
Example 1: Calculating 13 - 8
- •Step 1: Set 13 on the soroban (1 in tens, 3 in ones)
- •Step 2: Analyze - you want to subtract 8 from ones, but only 3 is there
- •Step 3: Find the complement - 8's complement is 2 (because 8 + 2 = 10)
- •Step 4: Execute - Subtract 1 from tens column, add 2 to ones column (3 + 2 = 5)
- •Step 5: Read result - 5
Example 2: Calculating 15 - 7
- •Step 1: Set 15 on the soroban (1 in tens, 5 in ones)
- •Step 2: Analyze - you want to subtract 7 from ones, but only 5 is there
- •Step 3: Find the complement - 7's complement is 3 (because 7 + 3 = 10)
- •Step 4: Execute - Subtract 1 from tens column, add 3 to ones column (5 + 3 = 8)
- •Step 5: Read result - 8
| Problem | Can Subtract? | Complement | Action | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 11 - 3 | No (only 1) | 7 | Borrow 10, add 7 | 8 |
| 14 - 6 | No (only 4) | 4 | Borrow 10, add 4 | 8 |
| 12 - 7 | No (only 2) | 3 | Borrow 10, add 3 | 5 |
| 15 - 9 | No (only 5) | 1 | Borrow 10, add 1 | 6 |
| 13 - 5 | No (only 3) | 5 | Borrow 10, add 5 | 8 |
| 16 - 8 | No (only 6) | 2 | Borrow 10, add 2 | 8 |
| 11 - 9 | No (only 1) | 1 | Borrow 10, add 1 | 2 |
| 17 - 8 | No (only 7) | 2 | Borrow 10, add 2 | 9 |
Combining 5-Complement and 10-Complement
This is where it gets interesting - and where many children need extra support. Some problems require BOTH complement techniques in the same calculation. Let's walk through this carefully:
Example: Calculating 8 + 6 (Combined Technique)
- •Initial: Set 8 (heaven bead + 3 earth beads)
- •Goal: Add 6, but 8 + 6 = 14 (needs carrying)
- •10-complement: Add 1 to tens, subtract 4 from ones
- •But wait: 8 - 4 can't be done directly (only 3 earth beads to remove)
- •5-complement needed: To subtract 4, remove 5 (heaven bead up), add 1
- •Result: 8 - 4 = 4 in ones, plus the 1 ten = 14
Combined techniques sound complex when explained step-by-step, but with practice they become one fluid motion. The key is mastering 5-complement FIRST, so it becomes automatic when needed within a 10-complement operation.
The Occupational Therapy Perspective
From my professional experience, the soroban 10-complement offers unique developmental benefits:
- •Bilateral coordination: Both hands work together, crossing the midline
- •Visual-motor integration: Eyes track beads while fingers manipulate
- •Sequential processing: Children must hold multiple steps in working memory
- •Spatial reasoning: Understanding that columns represent different values
- •Proprioceptive feedback: The physical sensation of bead movement aids memory
When to Introduce 10-Complement
Based on my experience with my three children and the families I work with, here's the typical readiness timeline:
- •Prerequisite: Solid mastery of 5-complement (usually 4-8 weeks of practice)
- •Age range: Most children are ready between ages 6-8
- •Signs of readiness: Can do 5-complement without thinking, understands place value basics
- •Caution: Introducing too early leads to confusion and frustration
- •Individual variation: Some children are ready at 5, others not until 9
Practice Exercises: Progressive Difficulty
Level 1: Pure 10-Complement Addition
- •9 + 2 = ?
- •8 + 3 = ?
- •7 + 4 = ?
- •6 + 5 = ?
- •9 + 5 = ?
- •8 + 6 = ?
Level 2: Pure 10-Complement Subtraction
- •11 - 2 = ?
- •12 - 4 = ?
- •13 - 6 = ?
- •14 - 8 = ?
- •15 - 7 = ?
- •16 - 9 = ?
Level 3: Mixed Addition and Subtraction
- •8 + 5 - 4 = ?
- •7 + 6 - 8 = ?
- •9 + 4 - 7 = ?
- •15 - 8 + 6 = ?
Common Mistakes and Solutions
- •Mistake #1: Using 10-complement when not needed - Solution: Always check if result exceeds 9 (addition) or if there's enough to subtract
- •Mistake #2: Wrong complement pair - Solution: Drill pairs regularly, use finger counting to verify
- •Mistake #3: Forgetting to carry/borrow - Solution: Verbalize 'Add 10' or 'Borrow 10' while practicing
- •Mistake #4: Confusing 5 and 10 complements - Solution: Master 5-complement first, introduce 10-complement gradually
- •Mistake #5: Errors in combined techniques - Solution: Slow down, do each step deliberately until automatic
Tips for Parents Teaching 10-Complement
- •Use consistent language: 'Add 10, subtract complement' or 'Borrow 10, add complement'
- •Practice pairs verbally before using the soroban: 'What's 7's friend of 10?' '3!'
- •Start with problems that DON'T need 5-complement too (simpler first)
- •Use Sorokid's visual feedback - children can see immediately if they made an error
- •Celebrate small wins - each new complement pair mastered is an achievement
- •Be patient - this technique takes months, not weeks, to become automatic
The combined 5 and 10 complement technique sounds complex, but with practice it becomes a single fluid motion. The brain automates the steps, and children eventually perform these calculations faster than they could ever do mental math without the soroban foundation.
Ready to help your child master carrying and borrowing the soroban way? Sorokid offers progressive complement training with visual feedback, adaptive difficulty, and progress tracking designed for busy families. Join thousands of parents who've discovered how the Japanese abacus transforms math learning.
Start Free Trial