My First Classroom Observation: Surviving the Fear, Pressure, and Hard-Won Lessons
A new teacher shares the raw emotions and practical lessons from her first formal classroom observation. From sleepless nights to shaking hands, discover how to survive your first observation and turn anxiety into professional growth.
I remember my first observation like it was yesterday, though it's been eight years. The night before, I didn't sleep. The morning of, my hands shook so badly I couldn't write on the board. For forty-five minutes, I felt like I was teaching underwater—everything distorted, slowed, surreal. When the observers finally left, I walked to the supply closet and cried. Not because the lesson went badly—honestly, I couldn't even tell you how it went—but because the pressure had been so intense that I needed to release it somehow. If you're a new teacher facing your first observation, this article is for you. I want you to know: what you're feeling is normal. The anxiety is real. And you can get through this. Here's everything I wish someone had told me before that terrifying Thursday morning.
The Week Before: A Descent into Anxiety
"Ms. Richardson, your formal observation will be next Thursday. The principal and department head will observe your third-period math lesson." Those words from my assistant principal hit me like a physical blow. I'd known observation was coming—it's part of every new teacher's evaluation—but hearing the specific date made it suddenly, terrifyingly real.
What I Did That Week
- •Rewrote my lesson plan five times
- •Asked veteran teachers to review it (they were kind but I second-guessed every suggestion)
- •Practiced teaching in my empty classroom after school
- •Searched "how to survive classroom observation" approximately 200 times
- •Had stress dreams every night—the kind where you show up to class naked or discover you're teaching the wrong subject
By Wednesday night, I had over-prepared to the point of paralysis. I had three backup activities, contingency plans for every possible disruption, and so many notes that I couldn't find the actual lesson anymore.
I prepared so much that I couldn't be present during the actual lesson. I was too busy remembering my script to actually teach. Sometimes adequate preparation is better than perfect preparation that makes you rigid.
The Night Before: The Longest Night
I tried to sleep at 9 PM. I lay in bed reviewing the lesson mentally, then worrying about what could go wrong, then mentally reviewing again. At midnight, I was still awake. At 2 AM, I got up to check my materials one more time. At 4 AM, I gave up on sleep and just lay there waiting for morning.
The physical symptoms were intense: racing heart, tight chest, nausea, that feeling like you've forgotten something critically important but can't remember what. I've since learned these are classic anxiety responses. At the time, I thought something was wrong with me.
The Morning Of: Hands That Wouldn't Stop Shaking
I arrived at school ninety minutes early. I checked the projector three times. I arranged and rearranged student desks. I wrote the day's objective on the board—or tried to. My hand shook so badly the words looked like a seismograph during an earthquake. I erased and rewrote four times before achieving barely legible text.
When students began arriving, I tried to act normal. "Good morning! Ready for a great math lesson?" My voice sounded false to my own ears—too cheerful, too tight. A student asked, "Ms. Richardson, are you okay? You look weird." Out of the mouths of babes.
The Observation: Forty-Five Minutes That Lasted Forever
At 10:15, the door opened. Principal Dr. Martinez and department head Mrs. Chen entered with clipboards and settled in the back corner. The lesson officially began.
What I Remember
- •My voice sounded strange—too fast, too high
- •I couldn't make eye contact with the observers; their presence felt like a physical weight
- •Every student question felt like a test I might fail
- •The clock moved impossibly slowly
- •I forgot one of my planned activities entirely
- •A student dropped a pencil and I startled visibly
- •When I tried to circulate the room, I couldn't remember why I was moving
What Actually Happened (I Found Out Later)
According to the observers, the lesson was... fine. Not spectacular, but competent. Students were engaged for most of it. My explanations were clear. The activity worked. I missed some opportunities for deeper questioning, but overall, it was a solid first-year lesson. I couldn't see any of this in the moment. My anxiety had distorted my perception so severely that I experienced a decent lesson as a catastrophe.
Our perception during high anxiety is unreliable. I was convinced the lesson was a disaster while it was happening. Observers saw something quite different. Don't trust your anxious assessment of your own performance.
The Aftermath: Processing the Experience
When the observers left, I had twenty minutes before my next class. I walked to the supply closet, closed the door, and cried. A veteran teacher found me there and didn't seem surprised at all. "First observation?" she asked. I nodded. "I cried too. We all did." That was the most comforting thing anyone could have said.
The Feedback Meeting
The post-observation meeting was scheduled for the next day—twenty-four hours of agonizing wait. I prepared myself for the worst. When Principal Martinez started with "I enjoyed watching you teach," I nearly collapsed with relief. The feedback was balanced: strengths in classroom management and clear instructions, growth areas in questioning techniques and wait time. Nothing devastating. Nothing career-ending. Just normal developmental feedback for a new teacher.
What I Learned: Lessons for Every New Teacher
Eight years and dozens of observations later, here's what I now understand about surviving that first formal evaluation.
Lesson 1: Your Anxiety Is Normal—And Universal
I thought I was uniquely terrified. I wasn't. Every new teacher I've met since has described similar experiences. The sleeplessness, the shaking, the surreal feeling during the lesson—these are normal responses to being evaluated in a high-stakes situation. You are not weak for feeling afraid. You are human.
Lesson 2: Observers Want You to Succeed
I imagined observers as judges looking for failures. In reality, administrators want new teachers to succeed. A struggling new teacher means more work for everyone—more support, more documentation, potentially a hiring failure. Observers are generally looking for evidence of competence, not searching for reasons to criticize.
Lesson 3: Adequate Preparation Beats Obsessive Preparation
My over-preparation hurt more than it helped. I was so focused on executing my script perfectly that I couldn't respond naturally to students. A lesson that's 80% prepared and 100% present is better than a lesson that's 150% prepared and 50% present.
Lesson 4: Physical Self-Care Matters
If I could redo that week, I would have: stopped preparing by 7 PM the night before, done a relaxation exercise before bed, eaten a real breakfast observation morning, done breathing exercises before students arrived, and accepted that some anxiety is unavoidable. Taking care of your body affects your mind's performance.
Lesson 5: The Observation Isn't About You—It's About Students
This reframe helped me in later observations: focus on whether students are learning, not on how you look teaching. When I shifted my attention from "Am I performing well?" to "Are my students understanding?", everything became clearer and calmer.
Practical Tips for Your First Observation
Before the Observation
- •Plan a lesson you've taught before successfully—don't experiment
- •Keep the lesson structure simple and predictable
- •Have one backup activity, not seventeen
- •Practice the lesson once out loud, then stop
- •Tell students an observer will be visiting (it helps them behave)
- •Prepare a one-page lesson overview for observers
The Night Before
- •Stop preparing by early evening—you know enough
- •Do something relaxing and unrelated to school
- •Avoid caffeine after noon
- •Practice deep breathing or progressive relaxation
- •Accept that you probably won't sleep well—that's okay
Morning Of
- •Eat something, even if you're not hungry
- •Arrive early enough to feel settled, not frantic
- •Do a final check of materials, then stop checking
- •Take three deep breaths before students enter
- •Remember: this one lesson doesn't define your career
During the Observation
- •Focus on students, not observers
- •Ignore the urge to perform—just teach
- •If you make a mistake, recover normally—observers expect imperfection
- •Don't apologize for things observers probably didn't notice
- •Breathe
When anxiety spikes during observation, pause for three seconds before responding to anything. This prevents panic responses and makes you appear thoughtful rather than reactive.
Handling the Feedback Meeting
The post-observation meeting can feel like a second test. Here's how to approach it productively.
- •Listen without defending—you'll process the feedback better if you're not arguing mentally
- •Take notes on specific suggestions, not just general impressions
- •Ask clarifying questions: "Can you give me an example of what that would look like?"
- •Request strategies, not just criticisms: "What do you suggest I try?"
- •Thank the observers genuinely—they gave you time and attention
- •Give yourself 24 hours before deciding whether feedback is valid
If It Goes Badly
Sometimes observations genuinely don't go well. Technology fails. Students misbehave. You blank on your lesson. If this happens, remember: One bad observation rarely has career consequences if you respond constructively. Ask for specific improvement plans. Request a follow-up observation to demonstrate growth. Document what you're doing differently. Reach out to mentors or instructional coaches for support.
Most teachers have a disaster story. What matters is your response. Administrators respect teachers who take feedback seriously and show improvement, more than teachers who perform perfectly but resist growth.
A Message to New Teachers
If your first observation is approaching and you're terrified, please know: You are going to be okay. The fear you feel is universal—it doesn't mean you're not cut out for teaching. The observation will end. You will receive feedback. Some of it will be helpful. Some of it might sting. And then you will teach again the next day, slightly more experienced than before.
Eight years after my first observation, I now serve as a mentor for first-year teachers. When they come to me shaking before their observations, I tell them about the supply closet where I cried. I show them that the terrified new teacher can become the confident mentor. You are braver than you believe, and more capable than you feel right now. You've got this.
Want engaging math lessons that captivate both students and observers? Sorokid provides teacher-friendly resources that make every lesson shine—even during observations.
Explore Teacher Resources